Newsletter
July 4, 2009
Search 
JUST IN
cxo_content_drill
Home
CXOtoday Storage
CXOtoday Plus
News
Industry Verticals
Tech Insight
Market Scan
Interview
CXO Lifestyle
CXO Views
Case Studies
White Papers
Editorial
Downloads
Specials
SMB Zone
TECH INSIGHT
SaaS: Opportunities and Challenges in India
Despite challenges, SaaS model is here to stay. Anita N, corporate communications, Calsoft talks about what these challenges are and how enterprises can overcome them to leverage SaaS benefits.
More...
MARKET SCAN
Broadband Internet Investment Beat Recession Blues
The urge to avoid commuting and green concerns have ensured investments in broadband Internet globally remain robust and are not pared down, finds a study.
More...
 Home > Editors Speak
Email Print View Comments   

The File Format Standards Conundrum
By Tabrez Khan
Mumbai, Mar 25, 2008 1111 hrs IST

India recently rejected Microsoft's document format Office Open XML (OOXML). The Bureau of Indian Standards voted against making Openxml an ISO standard. Microsoft, in a statement released subsequently, expressed deep disappointment at the bureau's rejection of OOXML. To put things in perspective, OOXML is the latest format of electronic documents such as spreadsheets, charts, presentations, word processing, etc. This was initially developed by Microsoft and later handed over to Ecma International. Ecma further developed it to action levels as a standard called Ecma 376. Microsoft has been gunning for the adoption of this format as a standard across the world, but the decision has been hanging fire by technical committees across the world. There's widespread sentiment that OOXML should not be considered even if supported as a standard. This may seem like taking it a bit too far but a careful analysis of the issue would reveal that this sentiment albeit far-fetched does have some plausible explanation. One major reason for such anti-XML sentiment is that Microsoft does not intend to support its own standard. According to Microsoft once OOXML becomes a standard, it will have a governing body outside of Microsoft therefore it cannot guarantee if that governing body's decisions will be acceptable by itself. One can imagine where this could lead to, especially in a scenario where MS holds more than 90% of the market share in office productivity suites. While the rest of the world will be hard put to keep up with OOXML, Microsoft itself will not be under any obligation to abide by those decisions of the governing body that it deems inconvenient. This, even when the new standard will be broadly compatible with its own products. The technical committee for the standard will have to forever keep playing the catch-up game after each change by Microsoft, especially since MS' changes are never properly documented. Meanwhile the ODF format developed by Organization for the Advancement of Structured Information Standards (OASIS) consortium is gaining currency among users. This is mainly because that it allows for more open archival formats, which will ensure readability by future word processors. The OOXML converters too seem to have a problem as they cannot convert between OOXML and ODF formats seamlessly. This is an extremely important feature for users and naturally OOXML's lack of compatibility on this front would also be looked at askance. Microsoft's overzeal to have the OOXML format adopted as a standard seems to have let these issues remain unaddressed. With these limitations, OOXML may at best acquire the status of a technical specification (TS) that does not the very high consistency and completeness criteria of a standard.

  Tags: The File Format Standards Conundrum  
  Share and Connect   Myweb MyWeb  Newsvine.comNewsvine.com 
  Recent news in Editors Speak
 
Indian Railway Leveraging IT, But Needs to Do More
Increase IT Spend, Encourage Small IT Companies
India Can Get Better as an Outsourcing Destination
Govt. Moves Expected to Boost Economic Sentiment
Obama Alert for US MNCs, not Indian IT Cos
 
 
Comment :

Name :
Company :
City :
E-mail :
Word verification : Type the characters you see in the picture below.
 
Characters are not case-sensitive
   

Comments
Report as offensive
I dont see this as a conundrum at all. I applaud India again taking a leadership position that doesn't put one company's interest above real world considerations for document standards.
-
dan trevino undisclosed gainesville, fl
26/03/08 02:06 AM
Reply

Disclaimer
ITNation (India) Pvt. Limited and its sites: www.channeltimes.com, www.techtree.com and www.cxotoday.com provide Comments and discussion boards as a professional medium for the various businesses of the IT industry to discuss business problems. Gossip, personal attacks and unsubstantiated charges are prohibited. Messages posted on this Web site as discussion threads or Comments (Content) are solely the opinions of their creators and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of ITNation (India) Pvt. Limited or its sites www.channeltimes.com, www.techtree.com and www.cxotoday.com.
All individuals who post material to this web site are solely responsible for all Content that they upload, post or otherwise transmit via the Web Site.
ITNation cannot vouch for the authenticity of the user or company names or e-mail addresses associated with posted messages. Under no circumstances will ITNation India Pvt.Ltd. or Cxotoday.com be liable in any way for any Content, including, but not limited to, for any errors or omissions in any Content, or for any loss or damage of any kind incurred as a result of the use of any Content posted or otherwise transmitted via the Bulletin Boards.
ITNation reserves the exclusive right to edit or remove messages containing inappropriate language or other material that could be construed as libelous, potentially libelous, or otherwise offensive or inappropriate. Discussion forums, bulletin boards and chat facilities are provided by ITNation solely for the convenience of those who make use of the service. ITNation does not endorse the products and services or other offerings mentioned in messages.
TODAY'S HEADLINES
Budget 2009
ESOPs should be made
Symantec's Quorum
BI to Manage Unstructure
Barrett Gives Intel-Noki
CXO VIEWS
Lean Six Sigma Makes Biz Customer Responsive
Lean Six Sigma (LSS) is a management concept that focuses on customer needs like no other process does, says Balaji Rajagopalan, executive director-Operations and LSS, Xerox. Rajagopalan dwells extensively on the LSS concept in an interview with Tabrez Khan
More...
LATEST COMMENTS
dear sir, i have a 2000 sq ft. space available ..
i WANT TO KNOW THE STATUS OF MY TICKET THROUGH ..
Dear Sirs, I am a previous customer of ..
hi,i am intersted to have mobile tower my ..
I am happy to say, "Corporate India has ..
MOST POPULAR STORIES
Nandan Nilekani to Quit (2)
Budget Expectations (2)
Satyam Computers is MS (1)
Idea Inks Rs 145 CrDeal (1)
HP Saves $1 Billion/Yr (1)
Copyright (C) 2009 ITNation India Pvt. Ltd. All Rights Reserved.